PHYASTRO / Physics notebook
How much ice melts in a mixture?
Check the energy balance before calculating temperature: complete melting or water and ice at 0 °C.
Reviewed on 28 October 2026
Ice can receive energy without changing temperature. During melting, energy changes the proportions of solid and liquid. Using only \(Q=mc\Delta T\) misses that stage. To find the temperature of an ice–water mixture, first check whether the available energy can melt all the ice.
The model and the data
Mix 180 g of water with 40 g of ice initially at 0 °C. Assume pure water at atmospheric pressure and a final state of thermal equilibrium. Ignore the container, heat exchange with the surroundings and evaporation. Use the constant working values \(c_w=4200\,\mathrm{J/(kg\,K)}\) and specific latent heat of fusion \(L_f=334000\,\mathrm{J/kg}\).
The value \(L_f\) tells us how much energy melts one kilogram of ice at its melting temperature; it is not a temperature. Melting all 40 g requires \(Q_{\mathrm{melt}}=0.040\cdot334000=13360\,\mathrm J\). The warmer water supplies energy as it cools towards 0 °C.
Water initially at 25 °C
Cooling the water to 0 °C could release \(Q_{\mathrm{available}}=0.180\cdot4200\cdot25=18900\,\mathrm J\). That exceeds the melting requirement. All the ice melts, and the remaining energy warms the whole mass of liquid water, including the water formed from the ice.
\[0.180c_w(25-T_f)=0.040L_f+0.040c_wT_f.\]\[T_f=\frac{18900-13360}{(0.180+0.040)\,4200}\approx6.00\,^\circ\mathrm C.\]A positive answer below 25 °C is consistent with complete melting. The final water mass is 220 g. We have not heated only the original 180 g: the 40 g of meltwater must reach the same final temperature.
Water initially at 10 °C
Only 7560 J is now available, which cannot melt all the ice. Water and ice coexist at 0 °C in the final equilibrium state. The melted mass is \(m_m=7560/334000\approx0.02263\,\mathrm{kg}=22.63\,\mathrm g\), leaving about 17.37 g of ice. Total mixture mass remains 220 g.
| Initial water temperature | Heat available to 0 °C | Final state |
|---|---|---|
| 25 °C | 18.90 kJ | All 40 g melts; about 6.00 °C |
| 10 °C | 7.56 kJ | 22.63 g melts;17.37 g ice remains at 0 °C |
Common mistakes
An arithmetic average of the starting temperatures ignores both masses and the phase change. A negative temperature obtained from a complete-melting equation shows that its assumption has failed. If the ice starts below 0 °C, first include the energy needed to warm it to its melting temperature.
Heat leaving the water and heat entering the ice have opposite signs. The equations above equate their positive magnitudes. A zero-sum energy balance must instead retain the opposite signs; mixing those two conventions produces an apparent energy imbalance.
Check the balance
Does a final temperature of 0 °C mean no heat was transferred?
No. The second trial transfers 7560 J and melts 22.63 g of ice. Temperature remains constant while the phases coexist under the stated conditions.
What happens exactly at the complete-melting threshold?
If available energy is exactly 13360 J, the last ice melts and all the resulting water remains at 0 °C.
How would a warm container with appreciable heat capacity affect the calculation?
The container would also release energy. Its mass, specific heat and initial temperature would enter the balance, so the results must be recalculated.